Observations from a newbie

wfin73 · Sep 24, 2014

So, after my first three months of smoking a pipe, I've come to some conclusions. First, I really like codger blends. After trying several aromatics, some Virginia, and even some Perique, i realize my favorites are the classics, Sir Walter Raleigh, Carter Hall, and even Half & Half. They just seem to smoke the best for me, easy to light, keep lit, and the least amount of bite. Also, my other realization, is that I really dig corn cobs. I have a decent LJ Peretti briar, but I find myself going back to the cobs. They burn great, keep cool, and give me the driest smoke so far. I can't get through a bowl with my briar without it gurgling at some point, but almost never my cob. I just got in a country gentlemen from P&C, I can't wait to try it out on my next smoke. What a robust pipe, I wasn't expecting it to be so big, but I love it!
Thanks to everyone here, you've all been a great source of information for this newbie!

johnnyreb · Sep 24, 2014

I like my cobs as well but I do change out the bits before I use them the first time. The MM Country Gentleman is my overall favorite and I keep several on hand. I also like the big Freehand and it is actually the best smoker with it's chimney effect; haven't tried the General but would expect it to be similar. My other favorite is the Great Dane Egg; never tried the Spool. I usually don't smoke cobs smaller than the Egg but I did buy 3 Morgan's when CVS had them priced at 75% off but haven't done anything with them yet.

cobguy · Sep 24, 2014

With several briars and enough different tobaccos to choke an elephant ... I still love CH in a cob.
Looks like you're discovering early on what takes some many years to come back around to.
You are going to LOVE that Country Gent and some CH is perfect to break it in ... congrats!

minfarshaw · Sep 24, 2014

I also tend to gravitate towards cobs. I love EMP in my Mark Twain.

cosmicfolklore · Sep 24, 2014

Carter Hall in a cob immediately makes me think of mowing the yard. My mower runs on Carter Hall.

virginiacob · Sep 24, 2014

There is something to be said about smoking the old "classic" OTC blends in a cob. Lately I've been enjoying smoking Half & Half in my Old Dominion cobs but I've also enjoyed CH, SWR, and PA in them as well. Another great classic burley blend that I've found that smokes well in a cob is Sutliff Tobacco Company's Heine's Blend. I tried a sample of this blend for the first time at the TAPS Pipe Expo in Raleigh back in April and afterwards bought a 14 oz. container.

cmdrmcbragg · Sep 24, 2014

I can't smoke OTCs anymore. To each his own, whether it is taste that drives one or finances.

smeigs · Sep 24, 2014

+1 on the carter hall and a cob. Great stuff I must say.

derfargin · Sep 25, 2014

Carter Hall is tops for me with OTC. Prince Albert gets the silver. My Country Gent gets the most work out of all my pipes.

mso489 · Sep 25, 2014

There's a reason codger blends have been around for more than a century, and cobs too.

cobguy · Sep 25, 2014

My mower runs on Carter Hall.

:rofl: You've been on a roll today Cosmic!

To each his own, whether it is taste that drives one or finances.

Looks like it's driving just a few folks and at a cost equal to or greater than many other blends:
316 Reviews with a 3.0 star rating:

http://www.tobaccoreviews.com/blend/1092/john-middleton-inc-carter-hall
378 Reviews with a 3.0 star rating

http://www.tobaccoreviews.com/blend/1207/prince-albert-prince-albert

newbroom · Sep 25, 2014

4mos. from one MMLegend and OHM to 14 cobs, about 10 smoking briars, a cherry wood, a meerschaum, and approximately 20 blends...I'm rotating about 12 pipes and have about 20 unsmoked or on hold, (which includes most of a bag 'o seconds and 9 Medico briars)
Codger blends on hand SWR, PA, CH. so far, I've not tasted enough CH to place it but it seems at first to be like a combo of SWR and PA....I like PA a tad bit more at this point.
My biggest tobacco revelation was Latakia for the first time with Newminsters Ultimate English. Once you get past the smell, and the first half bowl...you got something there. So tasty and smooth burning that it's the first time I've ever burned the stem on a cob.
Today I had the scary (somewhat) thought that this is just a passing fancy. That I've spent hundreds of dollars I wouldn't have otherwise spent on something that I'll drop within a few months.

simnettpratt · Sep 25, 2014

Carter Hall mixes well with 1Q. Cuts the sweetness of the 1Q with pure tobacco goodness. I also have more cobs than briars, and smoke them a lot. Favorite is the Country Gentleman, but I have a Freehand I haven't smoked yet, will have to try it! My General smokes well, and looks cool to me.

cosmicfolklore · Sep 25, 2014

Cheap? I keep getting this from Skip at The Briary who refuses to carry if for me as it is too expensive to be carrying that "cheap" tobacco. Actually, all bulks work out to being the cheapest, but most B&M's carry them. I'm not sure what the deal is. And, if it is the additives... they still carry Lane tobaccos, and those are just as laden with additives. I think it's just a stigma.

judcole · Sep 26, 2014

If you are enjoying simple burleys, give MacBaren Golden Extra a whirl. Simple, enjoyable flavor, and better quality tobaccos than the codger blends. MacB, C&D, Hearth & Home,and 4 Noggins all do good things with burleys. : puffy

:

wfin73 · Sep 26, 2014

If you are enjoying simple burleys, give MacBaren Golden Extra a whirl. Simple, enjoyable flavor, and better quality tobaccos than the codger blends. MacB, C&D, Hearth & Home,and 4 Noggins all do good things with burleys.

Next time I place an order, I might give it a try, I have MacBaren Virginia No.1 and already like that!

judcole · Sep 27, 2014

I just started with GE this year; I heard it was similar to Burley London, which is being discontinued. I grabbed a tin and liked it well enough to order a pound from JR. I can see it and H&H Beverwyck being the basis of a small burley rotation.

Observations from a newbie

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Site Sponsors

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Might Stick Around

Lifer

Lifer

Starting to Get Obsessed

Lifer

Can't Leave

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Might Stick Around

Lifer