I don't own a Mr. Brog, but I read mixed reviews. I think some of his non-briar wood can be less durable than briar, or likely is. Might work if you have a number of pipes. However, I would point out that you can get excellent buys on new Savinelli, Stanwell, BC, Chacom, Dr. Grabow, and other briar pipes that will last many decades or a lifetime. I'd just tend to recommend them as a long-term purchase. Some of the MM cobs that cost a little more have acrylic stems and will also last a long time. Buy a Mr. Brog if you like its looks, but for long-lasting quality, try one of the standard brand briars.