Jack Reid made me a fishtail replacement for my Peterson Bulldog which had a P-lip that did nothing for me. He did a great job, comfortably thin mouth piece shaped to match the pipe (which I had to send to him). The business was easy to conduct, he simply invoiced me when he sent my pipe back. It ended up costing me ~45 bucks plus the initial cost of shipping the pipe to him. Yours may be cheaper as mine had a diamond shank. It's made it back in to my rotation now so it was well worth it for me. Oh and he also polished up the silver band for me which I had neglected to do for about a year!