Meat Pie (Or why am I late to the party?)

blackadderlxx · Oct 22, 2018

Latakia, Oriental/Turkish, Virginia. Seems simple enough. I got a sample of Drew Estate's Meat Pie a little bit ago and have been really enjoying it. There's an interesting mild sour-ish kind of flavor which I assume is the orientals, and which I lack the adjectives to better describe. All I can say is that I really enjoy it. The only problem is that it apparently is no longer made. It seems as though there are quite a few blends which fit into this category: blends that I enjoy, but are no longer made. It's my fault for coming into the piping community at the tail end of the golden age. Which brings me around to the point of my post. A question, which is obvious...
Can anyone recommend an english blend that is similar to Drew Estates Meat Pie?

aldecaker · Oct 22, 2018

I always use "tangy" to describe orientals. Sour-ish seems to fit too, though. I've never had Meat Pie, so I can't compare it to anything else.

npod · Oct 22, 2018

You are lucky to have procured some Meat Pie. That was a very good blend and I miss it for sure. There is really no comparison, but Stokkebye PS52 Proper English does come to mind. You should try that. Drew Estate hit a home run with Meat Pie and it has a very light topping that tied it together, almost a crossover blend of sorts. Smoke your remaining stash in good health.

carolinachurchwarden · Oct 22, 2018

I think I have a tin of this sitting in my tub at the house. I still haven't cracked it open yet. I read a lot of good things about it, but just had too many things open to smoke on first before I get to it. I'm looking forward to it. It will be the first blend I will have an unopened tin of that is no longer in production. That's a first for me. Glad you enjoyed it. Once I crack mine, I'm sure I'll probably come back to report just how good it is and how much I will have enjoyed it wishing I had more, but alas.

prairiedruid · Oct 22, 2018

I also like Gatsby Luxury Flake by Drew Estates and was able to pick up a ton when it was clearance saled.

blendtobac · Oct 22, 2018

There is really no comparison, but Stokkebye PS52 Proper English does come to mind.

+1
Russ

doctorbob · Oct 22, 2018

I liked most of the Drew Estate pipe tobaccos, Meat Pie most of all. It's been gone for what? 3 or 4 years now?

901blends · Oct 22, 2018

I think all of the Meat Pie tins were produced in 2013, so the existing tins have had a long time to let any rough edges smooth.
I think the name "meat pie" didn't help this blend nor the name "drew estate".
I still see these occasionally at B&Ms when I travel.
Meat Pie as a name would probably work better for some matured red virginia, dark fired, perique blend where the resulting tangy smoky tin note reminds you of barbeque.

blackadderlxx · Oct 22, 2018

I think all of the Meat Pie tins were produced in 2013, so the existing tins have had a long time to let any rough edges smooth.
I think the name "meat pie" didn't help this blend nor the name "drew estate".
I still see these occasionally at B&Ms when I travel.
Meat Pie as a name would probably work better for some matured red virginia, dark fired, perique blend where the resulting tangy smoky tin note reminds you of barbeque.

Have we met? (;

blackadderlxx · Oct 22, 2018

+1 Russ

@Russ thanks for chiming in. Love your blends!

blackadderlxx · Oct 22, 2018

I've got PS Proper English on the list for my next order. I've always heard good things but haven't gotten around to that one yet. One that I did see on TR.com as a similar was Westminster which I do have and tried a bowl again since it's been a while but it doesn't have that same tangy/sour thing from the meat pie. Of course as 901blends pointed out, this would be aged meat pie as well. Which sounds gross because of the food connotation but is a really delicious medium english.

blackadderlxx · Nov 16, 2018

So I just tried some PS proper English for the first time. It's definitely the best PS lat blend I've tried. It reminds me of Meat Pie enough that I think I will survive. Thanks everyone for the input.

Search

Search

Meat Pie (Or why am I late to the party?)

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Site Sponsors

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

blackadderlxx

Can't Leave

aldecaker

Lifer

npod

Lifer

carolinachurchwarden

Lifer

prairiedruid

Lifer

blendtobac

Lifer

doctorbob

Part of the Furniture Now

901blends

Lurker

blackadderlxx

Can't Leave

blackadderlxx

Can't Leave

blackadderlxx

Can't Leave

blackadderlxx

Can't Leave