McClelland 2020 - Whats An Equivalent Tinned Version?

birko · Sep 28, 2016

I have really grown fond of McClelland's 2020 matured cake. It has a strong and rich oriental character and I'm a big oriental fan. Not much nicotine but worth it for the flavor alone. According to McClelland the main oriental in it is Xanthi.
Is there a premium tinned version or has anyone had another McClelland blend which is similar? One of the grand oriental series perhaps?
Birko

pipesmokingtom · Sep 28, 2016

I'll be that guy.
Why do you want to get a tinned version and pay more for the packaging?

fitzy · Sep 28, 2016

Take a look at the grand orientals line.
It's funny I love a ton of their tins and in particular the grand orientals line but I have a hard time liking 2020 and most of their bulk tobacco's for some reason.

balkisobrains · Sep 29, 2016

Full disclosure, I don't think that I have smoked 2020, but based on the description, probably "Blakeney's Best" is what you want. : puffy

:

skraps · Sep 29, 2016

I'm with Tom on this. I'm always stumped when people say they found a bulk they like and then they want to know where they can spend more money on it so that it's in a little tin. :crazy:

pagan · Sep 29, 2016

Why do you want to get a tinned version and pay more for the packaging?

+1, or settle for something beside what you like

hawky454 · Sep 29, 2016

I buy tinned for the cellar. It already comes with a little bit of age and it's already in it's perfect environment. A lot of times the tinned tobacco is "fresher", sometimes the bulk tobaccos can dry up at the retailers, thus losing a lot of flavor. I don't think it's weird at all. A lot of people prefer the the tin over bulk.

skraps · Sep 29, 2016

@Hawky - I don't disagree with that. All valid points. I guess I'm simply saying, if you have a blend in bulk that you like, and the same blend is NOT offered in a tin, why settle for an alternative simply to have the tin.

lestrout · Sep 29, 2016

Yo bir - to answer your original question, the tin that jumps to mind is No.24 from the Matured Virginia series in the brown labels. But there are significant differences, since the Oriental varietal is Drama rather than Xanthi and 2020 has some Latakia. The Virginias are not as bright. Likely there will be a large age difference if you were to buy both at the same time. The tins will probably have some some age on them, plus McClelland pre-ages them; whereas bulks at stores with fast turnover will be younger.
hp

les

tmb152 · Sep 29, 2016

I buy tinned for the cellar.

I am with most others on this, if you love a bulk blend, then why not just put it in a jar (or a tin) to store or carry it. Of course once you open a tin, it really isn't a very good container for long, you wouldn't want to leave it in for years. I cellar some tins because I HAVE to, not because I want to. Each holds too small a quantity, they can leak, rust, have those crappy FDA labels on them, couldn't care less about the art because I don't sit in my cellar and stare at them, and with jars, YOU have control on how they are stored and can look through the glass to see if any problems are developing, not open the tin months or years later only to get a big disappointment.

Search

Search

McClelland 2020 - Whats An Equivalent Tinned Version?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Site Sponsors

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

birko

Lurker

pipesmokingtom

Lifer

fitzy

Lifer

balkisobrains

Lifer

skraps

Part of the Furniture Now

pagan

Lifer

hawky454

Lifer

skraps

Part of the Furniture Now

lestrout

Lifer

tmb152

Can't Leave