Hmmm. Everyone has to figure out their own relationships. Complaints about ones breath can be legitimate, might even signal a loving concern. This is way too subtle for an up or down vote. But about the breath. This could be a body chemistry problem, based on the blends you smoke, or based on some other process with your digestion or gums, that has little to do with the tobacco. Maybe not immediately, but when you go to the dentist, you might have him/her look at your gums. A question: Do you have any aftertaste or off tastes when you smoke as compared to when you don't? I've had problems with taste and pipe smoking, in the distant past. I think certain flavoring in aromatics, over time, give me distinct taste problems. Meantime, try a milder and/or simpler blend. Sometimes a plain burley or a plain Virginia will give you less trouble this way. I'd try a few things and see what helps. Treat your relationship, for now, as a separate issue. If your woman friend finds a number of other complaints unrelated to pipes, then maybe it's time for counseling (if it's worth it to you) or a parting of the way. But not on the basis of this one complaint.