How old is too old?

It all depends on a lot of different variables really...
...Virginias are said to fare the best, gaining more sweetness with age, with reports of 80 year old stuff being divine, I think Turkish pretty much remains the same, Latakia can lose its kick or oomph and go over-the-hill, but still provide a unique experience, I recently found some old Dobie's #7 Blend and the Lat was ghostly yet added a certain subtle rumbling thunder in the background...contrary to many reports, I personally think that a quality Burley gains depth with age...
...the container often can dictate how the bacca has fared, whether or not it has kept its seal over the years.
Dry tobacco can most certainly be rehydrated, but in most cases once the "essential oils" have evaporated or whatever, the blend is only a shadow of its former fresh self...
...that said, I've enjoyed a good bit of old dried tobacco after rehydration and find the effort to be worth the trouble.
I prefer to use the bowl with wet towel on top rehydration technique, as this has fared well for me.
What was the blend or brand you found?
Any pix?
I love the romance of the old stuff!
Congrats on the supercool find!
:: :puffpipe: :: :puffpipe: :: :puffpipe: ::

:puffpipe: :: :puffpipe: :: :puffpipe: :: :puffpipe:

It depends of course. I still wouldn't suggest a 1969 tub of Mixture 79 but if it was Balkan Sobranie there would be people offering their first born children for it.

You don't say what the blend is. I subscribe to a method used by Rich Esserman for reviving dry, aged tobacco. Mix it with a fresh tin of the same or some other,complimentary blend. And as far as how old it too old. I was able to enjoy a pipeful of a 1948 vintage can of Edgeworth Ready Rubbed back in 1995. It was, of course, rather dry but smoked very well. A memorable smoke.
Mike S.

(OyVeyBay link)


You have another chance....

Let us know. Very interesting find.

If I were to find a tin of Three Nuns of that vintage, I'd be all over it ... my best guess is that there will be a limit as to how much re-hydration can be achieved, but if it were me, my inclination would be to take it slow and easy on that process ...

If you want to sample your find now, fill a pipe, place your kisser over the bowl and breathe some humidity into it. This will give you some idea of what you've got without the wait.
Mike S.

Ditto what Mike Stanley said.