If you are more of an aromatic smoker I would suggest giving W.O. Larsen Signature Vintage Mixture, Lane 1Q, Captain Black and Amphora a go.
I myself have never had a heady memorable pipe and tobacco moment while smoking aromatics unless they were Lakeland tobaccos from Gawith and such. My most memorable smokes have come from Va, Va/perique, and Latakia containing blends. There are so many "favourite" tobaccos of mine that I have a hard time naming just a few. Stick with blenders like Dunhill, Samuel Gawith, Gawith and Hoggarth, Esoterica, Solani, G.L. Pease, Cornell and Diel, Mclelland, Fribourg and Treyer, A&C Peterson, Rattrays, Peterson and Dan Tobacco and you might just find something that grabs a hold of you and will not let go. I have made many life long tobacco friends from that list. Good luck in your quest for the perfect blend. You will soon be locked in the clutches of PAD.
I'm currently in mega love with G.L. Pease Telegraph Hill, Samuel Gawith Squadron Leader and Full Virginia Flake, Fribourg and Treyer Cut Virginia Plug, Reiner Long Golden Flake, and Dan Tobacco's Hamborger Veermaster. But I couldn't smoke any of them all day long. I'm not really an all day smoker in all fairness so I just pick the blend and pipe to suit the moment.
Good luck dealing with this affliction called PAD.