Fake Dunhill

ciceronian

Lurker

Feb 13, 2014

9

0

• Feb 22, 2014

• #1

A gift from the lady. Beautiful thought but I feel fairly confident she got taken. Thoughts?
http://imgur.com/x2iwdM2
http://imgur.com/G7kCh39
http://imgur.com/fqQWtgZ
http://imgur.com/EoxXXZU
http://imgur.com/WezKZng

 

jthomas04

Might Stick Around

Oct 15, 2013

72

0

• Feb 22, 2014

• #2

What makes you think it's not legit? Shape numbers correct, wording looks legit, just the made in england got cut off.

 

dmcmtk

Lifer

Aug 23, 2013

3,672

1,685

• Feb 22, 2014

• #3

Why do you think it isn't real? Looks like a Dunhill from 1976 is my best guess. 4204 is a saddle stem Bulldog, which your pipe is. The lower lip of the button looks like it was sanded down a bit at some point. What exactly are your concerns?

 

chispa

Can't Leave

Sep 18, 2011

300

5

• Feb 22, 2014

• #4

Looks real to me too.

 

woodsroad

Lifer

Oct 10, 2013

11,794

16,147

SE PA USA

• Feb 22, 2014

• #5

Your woman done good for you.

 

ciceronian

Lurker

Feb 13, 2014

9

0

• Feb 22, 2014

• #6

The fact that the stamp is a touch off center. That and the stem took a good bit of wiggling and elbow grease to get it flush. Other than that, I'm praying its legit because I love the shape and it'd be my first Dunhill.

 

dmcmtk

Lifer

Aug 23, 2013

3,672

1,685

• Feb 22, 2014

• #7

Be careful with the stem! If you need to swab out the mortise with q-tips and iso, do it! Don't try to put the stem in if the briar is wet, or of course, take it out when it is hot. To get an easier fit you can use the lead pencil trick or the ivory soap trick. The stampings being off center should be of no concern, especially on a shape where there is so little real estate to put them, I know I've seen it before, as I'm sure others have.

 

allan

Lifer

Dec 5, 2012

2,429

7

Bronx, NY

• Feb 22, 2014

• #8

Cicero
Grab a hold of her and give her a big kiss and a great big thank you!
One Rare woman

 

ciceronian

Lurker

Feb 13, 2014

9

0

• Feb 22, 2014

• #9

@soymilk, interesting how the reddit opinions deviate so sharply from here, eh? Don't know what to make of hat, but essentially I still feel unclear.

 

dmcmtk

Lifer

Aug 23, 2013

3,672

1,685

• Feb 22, 2014

• #10

The drilling is off center? How do you mean that?

 

tuold

Lifer

Oct 15, 2013

2,133

166

Beaverton,Oregon

• Feb 22, 2014

• #11

I can imagine what the craftsman said just after he hit the stamper with his hammer.

 

captainsousie

Lifer

Aug 1, 2012

4,603

5,160

• Feb 22, 2014

• #12

Without inspecting the pipe in person, I couldn't tell you for sure. I can tell you that the problems look relatively minor and don't, in themselves, indicate a fake to me.

 

woodsroad

Lifer

Oct 10, 2013

11,794

16,147

SE PA USA

• Feb 22, 2014

• #13

It's a very nice pipe.

And although it's not perfect, it is a gift of love.

 

taerin

Lifer

May 22, 2012

1,851

1

• Feb 22, 2014

• #14

Probably a real Dunhill with a replacement stem, replacement stems are really common.

 

mso489

Lifer

Feb 21, 2013

41,210

60,459

• Feb 23, 2014

• #15

Are you anywhere near a pipe shop that deals new and estate Dunhills? A pro could probably suss out authenticity

fairly quickly through visual cues, and by handling the pipe. I want to go along with Forums members who think

this is a Dunhill with a replacement stem. But knock-offs are always with us, a huge industry of pirated goods. In

any case, they are correct in attributing the best to your woman friend who has done a bountiful kindness. The pipe

has great value for that, no matter who manufactured it.

 

dmcmtk

Lifer

Aug 23, 2013

3,672

1,685

• Feb 23, 2014

• #16

Ok, look at the picture of the button end of the stem. The slot ends a basically the same distance from the ends on both sides, now forget the slot, and look at the shape off the button, it's not symmetric. Again, I would say, at some point someone worked on the stem, probably to remove bite marks. If it were a replacement stem these things would be less likely both in the case of it having been made from a blank, and especially if someone had hand cut a new stem.

 

taerin

Lifer

May 22, 2012

1,851

1

• Feb 23, 2014

• #17

Not everyone that makes stems is good at it and not everyone that owns a Dunhill gets the expensive stem maker's stem. A lot of pipers just chew their stems to bits every couple years and replace them with fairly cheap ones, myself included.

 

rx2man

Part of the Furniture Now

May 25, 2012

590

11

• Feb 23, 2014

• #18

Wish my wife would get me a "fake" Dunhill

 

edgreen

Lifer

Aug 28, 2013

3,581

15

• Feb 23, 2014

• #19

How does it smoke? Your girl apparently went to a lot of trouble to find just the right pipe. The only way she got taken is if the pipe doesn't fill you with happiness and joy. If you enjoy the pipe, don't worry whether it's fake or not. The only time it would matter is if you went to sell it and, personally, I would never consider selling the pipes my wife has gifted me. Let her see you enjoying the smoke and don't let her see you doubting its "authenticity".

 

tuold

Lifer

Oct 15, 2013

2,133

166

Beaverton,Oregon

• Feb 23, 2014

• #20

Is it possible the pipe could have slipped out the backdoor of the Dunhill workshop as a reject? I've read of that happening with other pipe makers. An employee takes the pipe the home and end up in an estate sale somewhere.