Does the "10 Pipe Grab Bag of Smokable Seconds" worth the money?

ravid98 · Oct 9, 2016

I was thinking about ordering the "10 Pipe Grab Bag of Smokable Seconds" deal of "missouri corn cob". The ten corn cob pipes cost 34 dollars, including shipping.

Do you guys think it worth the money?. Some people say it is a great deal, while others think it is not. While it is a relativity cheap price for 10 pipes, I am kind of low on funds. I do not have a pipe, or rather, a stem for my briar pipe, which my house cleaner broke. I think it might be a great way to start my rotation. What do you guys think?

ericusrex · Oct 9, 2016

Since I was unfamiliar with the different styles of CC pipes, and not sure of what I'd like, I got a bag about two years ago. I got a good assortment that I'm still smoking. One has begun to burn through the side but I'm still using it until it's total toast. It is the luck of the draw though. If you get a bunch of those mini CCs then you may not be happy. I thankfully got none of those. So, in closing (ha!), I'd say if you know what style you like then you're better off just buying a few of those individually and not risking disappointment. But if you want to sample a bunch then the grab bag is a good buy.

Sjmiller CPG · Oct 9, 2016

Yes.

woodsroad · Oct 9, 2016

I'm working on my second bag.

pipesmokingtom · Oct 9, 2016

Some people say it is a great deal, while others think it is not.

I've literally never seen anyone say this isn't a good deal.
Get them. It's like $3/ea for smokable pipes.
In my experience, they make a conscious attempt to include variety. I've received two of the little pipes total in the last two bags. I, personally, really enjoy the small pipes.
I've gotten the higher end pipes in all bags, but probably 5/6 out of 10 are going to be the Legend/Washington Classic cob. Just makes sense as they make many times more of those than anything else.

pagan · Oct 9, 2016

Defiantly worth it, also a good way to discover what type of pipe you like, bent stem, straight, short poker etc..

pipesmokingtom · Oct 9, 2016

I do not have a pipe, or rather, a stem for my briar pipe, which my house cleaner broke.

Missed this on the first read. Wait, what?

hmhaines · Oct 9, 2016

Been thinking of getting this myself. If nothing else, you have a few pipes you can give to friends if they want to try smoking.
Seems like a great deal from a good little company.

woodsroad · Oct 9, 2016

Good catch, pipesmokingtom

" I am kind of low on funds. I do not have a pipe, or rather, a stem for my briar pipe, which my house cleaner broke. "

OK, help me out with this: Low on funds, yet you have a house cleaner

beefeater33 · Oct 9, 2016

Here's a thread I started a few years ago, when I first discovered the deal on the Smokeable Seconds. Still smoking them too- a GREAT deal IMO............

http://pipesmagazine.com/forums/topic/mm-cob-smokable-seconds-my-experience

pipesmokingtom · Oct 9, 2016

AND
No one hold me to this, but if you prefer bent vs. straight you can include a note with your order. Or if you prefer no ponies - likewise.
I've heard tell that they just may accommodate you.

jeepnewbie · Oct 9, 2016

I seen a bag before and they look like great buys. When I saw them I had limited funds and was looking for an artisan pipe.

zitotczito · Oct 9, 2016

I just got another bag to have on hand. 8 were Legend/Washington's and two Great Dane's and 2 mini's for 12 in total. I think they can be a fair as they can, some bags better than others but still a great deal. All of the pipes from my previous bag and still going strong.

andrew · Oct 9, 2016

I have one I got in a box pass 2 years ago and it still smokes great and is in great shape. There were even some hardwood pipes in the bag I grabbed my pipe from. So I would say yes it's a good deal, but can you part with 34 dollars?

jaq6q · Oct 9, 2016

Yes, it is a GREAT deal!

metalheadycigarguy · Oct 9, 2016

Definitely a great deal! I've ordered the grab bag twice. The first time was so I could give all my poker buddies their own pipe for when we would play poker at my house. The second time I split a bag with a friend. I've never had a single issue with any of the pipes I've gotten out of the grab bags. All the pipes I've received look like firsts too.

pipesmokingtom · Oct 10, 2016

All the pipes I've received look like firsts too

Agreed. I haven't been able to figure out what led to any of them being rejected. Some of the cobs I've ordered individually at full retail have looked "worse" than the 2nds.

michiganlover · Oct 10, 2016

The MM grab bag is a great deal!
I bought one two years back. Mine was 7 Washington/ Legend/ Missouri Prides, 2 of the smaller cobs (I believe Eatons) , and one bent Diplomat.
Based upon what others have posted, you can expect 5-7 Legends/ Washington/ Miisouri Prides, and at least one of the larger cobs.
Some people have reported getting cobs from the Cobbit line, minus the church warden stems.
The deciding factor is how much you like the Legend style cobs, as they are most likely to be the bulk of the bag (being the Legend is their biggest seller).

pipesmokingtom · Oct 10, 2016

Some people have reported getting cobs from the Cobbit line, minus the church warden stems.

I can vouch. I got the wizard cobbit (biggest) bowl in my last bag.
My last two bags have included that wizard cobbit, the acorn diplomat, the spool, the colonel (diplomat), a hardwood.

jabo · Oct 12, 2016

Probably can't beat it. Makes a good by for give away pipes.

Does the "10 Pipe Grab Bag of Smokable Seconds" worth the money?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Site Sponsors

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Lurker

Lifer

(sjmiller)

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Part of the Furniture Now

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Part of the Furniture Now

Lifer

Lifer

Might Stick Around

Lifer

Lifer

Can't Leave

Lifer

Can't Leave