Could some pal help me verify the authenticity of this Peterson?
- Thread starter gamxiaoyuan
- Start date
SmokingPipes.com Updates
Watch for Updates Twice a Week
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
- Status
@tppytel
Thanks buddy. I'm in China where forgeries are everywhere. Someone offers me a deal of 50$ for a new one that he brought 2 years ago. I'm thinking whether to take it or not.
Thanks buddy. I'm in China where forgeries are everywhere. Someone offers me a deal of 50$ for a new one that he brought 2 years ago. I'm thinking whether to take it or not.
There's no way that anyone can "verify" the authenticity of this pipe without actually inspecting it in person. Because it's an entry level Peterson, there seems to be little reason to go to the trouble of making a fake. But as you're in China, where forgery makes up a significant percentage of the economic activity, the odds shift a little. BTW, there is a large fill in the rim of this pipe. You might want to look it over carefully. But even if it's a fake, if it's a good smoker, who cares? You're not buying a collectible.
OK, didn't realize you were in China. I compared it to a recent Peterson Aran off my shelf and the stamping looks identical, right down to sizes and shapes of letters. $50 is a fine deal on an Aran if you like the shape. I love the series too, and own a couple of them. They're fine smokers for the price and the color deepens nicely with age.
@sablebrush52
Thanks pal. I'm afraid I have to agree with you about the Chinese economic thing, although I'm a native Chinese.
Thanks pal. I'm afraid I have to agree with you about the Chinese economic thing, although I'm a native Chinese.
I'm no expert, but that isn't exactly a choice cut of briar, is it?
That fill or flaw on the rim would be a deal breaker for me if that were a new pipe.
Is that typical for quality for that line?
That fill or flaw on the rim would be a deal breaker for me if that were a new pipe.
Is that typical for quality for that line?
Arans are a low end line for Peterson, so grain quality is hit-or-miss. You can find nicely grained ones if you're patient and lucky - I have two, a cross-cut and a straight grain, both very tight. But I've seen plenty online with washy grain like that one. Fills are to be expected at that level as well, though I agree that's a rather glaring one on the rim. My Arans have fills, but much smaller and less conspicuous than that. Overall, I'd say the pictured pipe is a relatively weak cosmetic example compared to the Arans I've seen.
@Russ - Do you have an Aran in hand, or only the higher grades? I understand what you're trying to describe, but both of my Arans have "soft" stamping exactly like what's shown in the picture. Details match right down to the location of the raised metal bits in the interior of the big P. I have other Petes with crisp stamps, but the Arans don't appear to use the same kind of equipment.
- Status