A Perfect Storm Replacement Stem (pic heavy)

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

48 Fresh Savinelli Pipes
23 Fresh Bruno Nuttens Pipes
6 Fresh Castello Pipes
2 Fresh Former Pipes
24 Fresh Rossi Pipes

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Status
Not open for further replies.

georged

Lifer
Mar 7, 2013
5,530
14,178
I haven't posted any shop work in a while because it's usually a case of "same thing, different day". Seen one, you've seen 'em all.
This one was rather the opposite. At first glance it looks simple enough, but it was anything but. One of the five or so toughest projects I've come across.
Here's the technical story:
There are several stummel shape details that make creating a replacement stem for it (in this case a second, switchable stem) especially difficult.
One is when the shank is square or square-ish; another is when there are small radii involved; another is a mortise that is not centered; and still another is when the shank is neither parallel-sided nor tapered, but flared.
On the stem side of the equation the categorical killers are length---the longer a stem is, the harder it is to keep things straight---and if it is faceted. (Every variation of round, oval, and bladed are a walk in the park compared to cutting gemstone-like facets with straight edges. The reason is because "there is only one straight line" in geometry, and the slightest deviation from it can be seen by a 16 year old pug dog from thirty feet away.)
So, imagine my joy when someone wanted a replacement stem that required dealing with ALL those things. :lol: An extra-long faceted stem for a stummel that WASN'T STRAIGHT ANYWHERE. Compensating for the offset and dimensional inequalities to make everything LOOK straight in the end was the name of the game
Anyway, that's the background, here are the pics. The first three show the shape of the shank, the second shows how far off center things were (the stem was inserted upside down to illustrate), and the third shows the slight trumpeting of the shank (the side view isn't shown but it also flared). The next three show the sausage being made, and the last three show the final result.
-
P1000892.jpg


P1000890.jpg


Long_stem_final_4.jpg

-
P1052930.jpg


P1152972.jpg


P1152982.jpg

-
Long_stem_final_1.jpg


Long_stem_final_2.jpg


Long_stem_final_3.jpg


 
M

mothernaturewilleatusallforbreakfast

Guest
You accomplished the square peg in round hole thing with this one seamlessly. Nice work as usual, and as always thanks for the post with the pics.

 

toobfreak

Lifer
Dec 19, 2016
1,365
7
Well, I can sure see how difficult that might have been! Making everything look ruler perfect when nothing at all lines up! All I can say is that the results looks flawless. Beautiful. Magnificent.
"there is only one straight line" in geometry
By that I'm guessing you mean there can only be one point of reference. Not sure what you might use as a reference here, but if I had to guess, I would guess the draft hole the stem fits into. That is the one thing you must deal with that you cannot change and everything else must be brought into line to look right in dealing with it.
But whatever the case, the completed pipe exudes perfection far beyond what the casual eye can ever know.

 

georged

Lifer
Mar 7, 2013
5,530
14,178
Cool that yer diggin' it. 8)
Also, thanks for the kind words. :D
And a P.S. -- The problems described aren't nearly the result of something Bjorn did or didn't do as much as the geometry inherent to the shape / design. The pipe wasn't INTENDED to have a 4-inch taper stem. Few (if any) pipe makers consider whether or not what he's making will present difficulties for a future repairman, in any event. Except for a few fundamental things, it isn't their job. No foul there, at all.
Having the full array of things that make a stem replacement difficult converge in one specimen was just luck, which is why I took the pics & etc. Like a reverse lottery win, or something. Noteworthy because of its rarity. :lol:

 

buroak

Lifer
Jul 29, 2014
1,867
14
I haven't been to a World's Fair, but I have been to a picnic and a rodeo, and that is the most stupefying stem creation I have ever seen come across a computer monitor.

 

georged

Lifer
Mar 7, 2013
5,530
14,178
Damn, guys. Thanks again for the props. :D
Repair work is such a limited interest thing that knowing people care about it (besides the actual owners of the pipes, of course) is exciting for me.
Someone called me tonight to ask if there were any "tricks" involved in keeping things straight on long, geometric stems like this BingDog, so I figured there might be others who are wondering who didn't ask.
So here ya go: At all times until the very end of shaping when it must be erased, keep a guide line in place. I start with a 1/8" strip of masking tape that's exactly centered over the slot, and lay it down tight and straight to the center of the "peaks" on the sides of the shank. Then, as the stem reduces to the point that tape can't be maintained, use the roughened, different color surface of the stem itself as a stripe. Think sharpening a knife edge but never quite getting there, leaving the edge slightly square in cross section. If you look closely at the second pic, what almost looks like a strip of tape is actually just vulcanite that's a lighter color because it has a rougher surface that holds dust.
The rest is just understanding what "dwell time" is when sanding and filing, and checking often both by sighting down all straight lines and using a machined straightedge to check for light gaps.
.
Long_Triangular_re_stem_2.jpg

P1152979.jpg


 
Status
Not open for further replies.