I'll second what woodsroad said. In my opinion Pipestud's Consignment Shop is without peer and I can recommend it wholeheartedly, as I have made multiple purchases from him with NO problems.
Steve Fallon (pipestud) is one of the most reputable dealers in the business as well as being a great guy. Personally, I trust him implicitly. When buying vintage tins there is always a chance that the tin has been compromised, Steve inspects all his offerings carefully and if he has the slightest doubt about a tin he will note it in his description.
Steve Fallon (aka Pipestud) is a paragon of virtue and an all around nice guy.
I have purchased MANY pipes from him on Ebay and when I had a question about one, he emailed the ARTISAN and got me an answer in less than 24 hours.
I have also purchased a good many tins from his consignment site. He bills and ships CRAZY fast.
I live in WA and his packages from TX frequently take 2-3 days.
He is a superstar.
I think my last feedback on ebay for him was, "minor diety" or somesuch. lol
Steve is a great guy. Ordered from his site and his auctions many times. Also was lucky enough to enjoy a smoke with him at the KC Pipe Show. Plus he beat me in the slow smoke contest! (although so did all but one other guy...)