Very sad. The body count for Middleton Cherry just keeps growing.Maybe, though I would be in your camp were it not for one man at my church. He died when I was still a small child but one of my earliest memories is of him sitting in his New Yorker finishing his pipe before making his way to the sanctuary. The smell was of an aromatic, probably an OTC like Middleton's Cherry. He was a tall, largish man with a kind nature. A good nature and pipe smoking were thus associated in my mind from an early age. I was set to be a pipe smoker before I could ride a bike.