Sutliff Private Stock Blend No. 5 Review | The #1 Source for Pipes and Pipe Tobacco Information
Sutliff Private Stock Blend No. 5 Review     September 3rd, 2013

E. Roberts
I recently re-evaluated my summer rotation,
adding more Latakia blends and boy am I glad I did. The pleasures of these summertime Lat-itudes have been eye-opening, and I encourage all of you to break out of prescribed habits, at least once in a while, to ensure that smoking not become an overly regimented exercise.

Moving on to another warm-weather discovery, this month’s adventure is taken with Sutliff Private Stock’s Blend No. 5. The journey begins with the tin itself: the artwork decidedly modernist, abstracting the number 5 and offering the descriptive text of, "BALANCED SMOKING TOBACCO—COOL WITH A RICH FLAVOUR". Is this an act of modernist art in itself—rejecting the formalism of touting one’s ingredients, making meta-commentary on the literary tradition of advertising copy—or merely, as my girlfriend suggests, “just the way they want to describe it?” Regardless, once the tin is opened the mystery of its contents becomes apparent: the Latakia in this blend is bold, assertive, and indeed well balanced with the pressed Virginia and burley that complete the trio. Styled as a robust English, the aroma does proclaim itself immediately on opening, but then relaxes a little with some airing time; the bouquet calms and the blend’s complexity becomes more apparent. Imagine the smell of a log cabin, slightly musty and humid; stoke the fire, toss on a log of sandalwood, and you can begin to have an idea of the aroma. The ribbons themselves are hearty, chestnut- and reddish-brown, streaked through with jet black. After regaling my girlfriend with a barrage of ruminations on the modernist camp, extolling the virtues of Dos Passos, and gently stoking the ember in my Sasieni billiard, it was obvious that I’d become both smarter and more attractive since opening the tin*. This was promising to be a good smoke.

“So have you had tobacco today?”

A tad humid in the tin, as mentioned, it bears some drying time to achieve my preferred smoking moisture level. Once realized, lighting it opens the cloak of the Latakia, revealing more fully the underlying flavors from the supporting cast. A mild sweetness is contributed after a slightly sharp, citrous opening note, and the burley adds the proper body to hang the other flavors on. 

It would be reductionist to say that the avant-garde movement rejected the old garde, as it were; it’s better argued that modernism was in fact the logical extension of its predecessors, and was rooted in a re-imagining of the ideal envisioned in expressionism and impressionism. Likewise, while this blend was apparently made as comparable to Dunhill’s 965, I don’t feel it was ever intended as a clone—it is, in fact, striking as a blend in its own right; one that references 965 as an homage within the idiom.


Blend No. 5 approaches the same general flavor profile as 965, but with its own character. Although overwhelmingly smoky in the tin, the flavor and aroma of the smoke itself is more subtly varied and nuanced when burning. Behind the Latakia’s earthy spice there is a constant sweetness, though mild, and hints of floral or herbal essences—at a turn honeysuckle, then sage. This dance continues from the top of the bowl through to the bottom, and with repeated bowls one can begin to appreciate the balance that is negotiated. Again and again I’m struck by the flexibility that the Latakia shows, from its boisterous introduction to a lingering peaty background aftertaste. It really covers the palate in this blend, and seems responsive to different pipes as well as different climates, taking on a much different aspect when enjoyed outdoors on a hot and humid evening as opposed to sitting in the office under the air conditioner. This kind of nuance is uncommon in many tobaccos, and it’s worth spending some time to get acquainted with it.

A winning pick.

Compliments will flow from those who enjoy the campfire aroma of Latakia, though non-smokers are likely to offer invectives, as #5 produces a thoroughly heady room note with a large volume of smoke. It’s a perfect companion for a lazy afternoon reading or writing, and lends itself to quiet contemplation rather than involved activity. More than once I had to slow my cadence down while chasing the sweet notes, and find that beverages with a slight dry or bitter character tend to make these notes stand out in relief a little better in the smoke. In general it does smoke coolly, as advertised, though aggressive puffing can push the Virginia to bite. It’s all about pacing. I would recommend this as an excellent introductory blend for those new to English styles and Latakia, as well as offering a superb value for the more experienced smoker, who will appreciate that it’s available in both 1.5-ounce and 8-ounce tins. Overall it’s made me stronger, smarter, and better looking* for the experience, so I picked up a lottery ticket before working on the photo shoot for this article—and wouldn’t you know it? I picked a winner.

(*-These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. Or my girlfriend.)


SPONSORED LINK: Read More About Blend No. 5 @ & Find a Retailer


Bookmark and Share



Comments Sponsored by: Sutliff Tobacco Co.

5 Responses to “Sutliff Private Stock Blend No. 5 Review”

  1. Cortez said:

    What an altogether nicely composed and well written article: entertaining as well as informative! The bottom picture was a nice touch too! ;)

  2. fnord said:

    Never in my life have I read a tobacco review that referenced John Dos Passos, so I’ll be go to hell.

    Let’s hook up someday and thrash out the U.S.A. Trilogy.

  3. fitzy said:

    Sounds like I have found yet another Sutliff blend to try.

  4. allan said:

    The comparison to Dunhill 965 (part of my regular rotation) has got me interested and I’m going to have to try a tin.

    Another beautifully written article

    Hey, we miss you at the pipe club!


  5. romeowood said:

    @Fnord: Remember, “If there is a special Hell for writers it would be in the forced contemplation of their own works.” Thank you all the same :D

    I’m really enjoying this series on the Sutliff line, and hope you all are as well.



Most Popular Articles

  • Sutliff Tobacco Unveils New Product Lineup For 2014
    Sutliff Tobacco Unveils New Product Lineup For 2014
    : Via Press Release - In keeping with the longstanding tradition of introducing innovative new product... 2 comment(s) | 2919 view(s) per day
  • Thoughts on Tobacco
    Thoughts on Tobacco
    : Fred Brown As I reflect upon our current condition, meaning the fraternity of pipe tobacco smokers,... 5 comment(s) | 1172 view(s) per day
  • The Pipes Magazine Radio Show - Episode 96
    The Pipes Magazine Radio Show - Episode 96
    : Kevin GodbeeThank you for joining us for The Pipes Magazine Radio Show—the only radio talk sho... 5 comment(s) | 1042 view(s) per day
  • Ask G. L. Pease (Volume 38)
    Ask G. L. Pease (Volume 38)
    : G. L. Pease I'm back from Kansas, and trying to recover from the fun. Pipe shows are great things, ... 3 comment(s) | 817 view(s) per day
  • Pipe Babe Gabrielle Smokes a Dunhill Cumberland
    Pipe Babe Gabrielle Smokes a Dunhill Cumberland
    : Gabrielle made her debut on in 2012. This is her 8th appearance as a Pipe Babe sin... 1 comment(s) | 788 view(s) per day
  • A Conversation With Myself
    A Conversation With Myself
    : Fred Brown Over the next weeks and months, I will endeavor to write a series of essays that will be... 13 comment(s) | 676 view(s) per day
  • The Good Old Days
    The Good Old Days
    : Allan Shinogle Those of us who have been around for 6 plus decades remember well when smoking in ... 6 comment(s) | 641 view(s) per day
  • Popcorn Corn Cob
    Popcorn Corn Cob
    : ... 0 comment(s) | 632 view(s) per day
  • Gina Roode Smoking a Corn Cob Pipe
    Gina Roode Smoking a Corn Cob Pipe
    : Say hello to our newest Pipe Babe, Gina Roode. Gina is a full time musician with an album of her own... 0 comment(s) | 565 view(s) per day
  • Show And Tell from the 2014 Chicago Pipe Show
    Show And Tell from the 2014 Chicago Pipe Show
    : Fred Brown CHICAGO—Well, the 2014 Chicagoland International Pipe & Tobacciana Show is in ... 1 comment(s) | 497 view(s) per day
  • Looking In Mirrors
    Looking In Mirrors
    : G. L. Pease Some years ago, a certain tobacco, one that was evidently quite popular, highly regarde... 21 comment(s) | 494 view(s) per day
  • New 4th Generation Tobacco: 1982 Centennial Blend
    New 4th Generation Tobacco: 1982 Centennial Blend
    : Via Press Release - Phillips & King International and Erik Stokkebye are delighted to announce t... 2 comment(s) | 483 view(s) per day
  • Pipeaholic
    : Russ Ouellette I admit it. I have a problem. Well, actually, I have a lot of problems, but I'm refe... 17 comment(s) | 483 view(s) per day
  • The Pipes Magazine Radio Show - Episode 91
    The Pipes Magazine Radio Show - Episode 91
    : Kevin GodbeeThank you for joining us for The Pipes Magazine Radio Show—the only radio talk sho... 6 comment(s) | 438 view(s) per day
  • Post-Show Reflections
    Post-Show Reflections
    : Russ Ouellette Every time I go to a pipe show, I come away with new information, or, at least, a ne... 25 comment(s) | 419 view(s) per day
  • The Pipes Magazine Radio Show - Episode 85
    The Pipes Magazine Radio Show - Episode 85
    : Kevin GodbeeThank you for joining us for The Pipes Magazine Radio Show—the only radio talk sho... 3 comment(s) | 411 view(s) per day
  • April 2014 Caption Winners Sponsored by & Savinelli
    April 2014 Caption Winners Sponsored by & Savinelli
    : We are pleased to announce the April 2014 Winners for the Cartoon Caption Contest ... 1 comment(s) | 406 view(s) per day
  • Hollywood Pipes
    Hollywood Pipes
    : Laurie Jacobson Hollywood has always been about looking good. That's why the pipe has been there si... 10 comment(s) | 403 view(s) per day
  • Smoothing Out Ruff Edges
    Smoothing Out Ruff Edges
    : James Foster I had first heard about some of Rik's custom tampers after seeing a tamper that looked... 3 comment(s) | 384 view(s) per day
  • Being a Tool
    Being a Tool
    : Russ Ouellette Lord knows that I have been called a "tool" by a number of people (along w... 12 comment(s) | 380 view(s) per day